Main Dish

The Story the Post Lost

January 28, 2010

For a brief few hours today, The Washington Post was praised for a gutsy blog post on washingtonpost.com that acknowledged the "disconnect" between the Post's editorials and its newsroom coverage of high-flying schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee. "Disconnect" is one way to put it -- "existing in parallel universes" would also be a fair description of the newspaper's reported facts about Rhee's ongoing management problems and PR blunders -- versus the endless, glowing praise heaped on her by the editorial page.

While Hardy school parents are justifiably outraged by the ongoing mismanagement of their school -- including the removal of a cherished principal -- Ellington students wonder if their institution will continue to exist in Georgetown, and DCPS teachers as a whole seem threatened with a new disparaging comment from the Chancellor each day, all one finds on the Post's editorial page is a Candide-like reverie showering compliments and applause.

Reporter Bill Turque, charged with reporting facts about Chancellor Rhee, finally spoke up about the contradiction on the newspaper's blog. City Paper quickly termed it the "Best Blog Post by the Post About The Post." But that link was broken several hours later and Turque's brave blog was no longer available.  Thanks to City Paper, here is Turque's blog "D.C. Schools Insider," in its entirety.

 

One newspaper, two stories - Bill Turque


Many of you may have noticed something more than a tad odd Tuesday morning in our coverage of Chancellor Rhee's now immortal comments to "Fast Company." My story, which appeared on the front of the Metro section, said that Rhee had yet to explain or elaborate, and that there would be no comment until later in the day. My Monday evening blog entry said pretty much the same thing


The editorial page told a different story.  Citing "information released by the chancellor's office on Monday," it said that of the 266 teachers laid off in October, six had served suspensions for corporal punishment, two had been absent without leave on multiple occasions, and one was on administrative leave for allegedly having sex with a student.


So, after asking DCPS about this since Friday--and being promised a response all day Monday--I read the answers in an editorial. Channel 4's Tom Sherwood also had Rhee's explanation on the air Monday.


But it's the disconnect between the editorial page and the news section that I feel requires some kind explanation. So let me try.


The news and opinion columns of The Post are wholly separate and independent operations. This assertion frequently draws a torrent of skepticism, but if this episode does nothing else, it should give the lie to the notion that there is some sort of sinister linkage. I have little-to-no contact with Jo-Ann Armao, who writes The Post's education editorials (full disclosure: Jo-Ann hired me in 2002 when she was the assistant managing editor for metro news; but we're all allowed a lapse of judgment now and then). About the only time we cross paths is at news events involving District education. Jo-Ann is a dogged journalist who pursues her own information.


That includes talking to Chancellor Rhee. And while I don't have their call sheets in front of me, I would wager that the Chancellor talks to Jo-Ann more than she does to me. (After a well-documented period of silence, the Chancellor started taking my calls and e-mails again last summer)


That's fine. Chancellor Rhee can obviously talk to whoever she wants about whatever she wants. While some of my colleagues don't agree, my view is that Jo-Ann isn't responsible for watching my back journalistically any more than I would be expected to align my reporting with her points of view.


The chancellor is clearly more comfortable speaking with Jo-Ann, which is wholly unsurprising. I'm a beat reporter charged with covering, as fully and fairly as I can, an often turbulent story about the chancellor's attempts to fix the District's public schools. The job involves chronicling messy and contentious debates based in both politics and policy, and sometimes publishing information she would rather not see in the public domain.


Jo-Ann, on the other hand, sits on an editorial board whose support for the chancellor has been steadfast, protective and, at times, adoring.


That's what editorial boards do. They form opinions and write about them. People can buy in.
Or not.


Where this gets complicated is that board's stance, and the chancellor's obvious rapport with Jo-Ann, also means that DCPS has a guaranteed soft landing spot for uncomfortable or inconvenient disclosures--kind of a print version of the Larry King Show. This happened last September during the flap over the out-of-boundary admission of Mayor Fenty's twin sons to Lafayette Elementary in Chevy Chase.


The chancellor repeatedly sidestepped questions about whether policies and procedures had been followed to place the kids in the coveted school. A few days after the dust settled, an editorial offered, without attribution, an "innocent explanation": the Fentys neighborhood school, West Elementary, had only one fourth grade class. Lafayette's multiple fourth-grade sections made it possible to separate the twins, which studies show is developmentally desirable.

Are Fenty and Rhee gaming the system by using the editorial page this way? Of course. Is this a healthy thing for readers of The Post? Probably not. Is it going to keep me from doing my job effectively?


Nope.


We agree. Georgetown residents -- and all other readers of the Post -- deserve better. (UPDATE: After furious reaction from the blogosphere, the Post re-posted a toned-down version of Turque's blog at 10:41 pm.)


Click here to share your thoughts.


Senator and Samantha Strauss Sparkle in Starbucks

January 26, 2010

It was a gray afternoon, but you'd never know it as Samantha Strauss, daughter of Sen. Paul Strauss, sauntered into Starbucks with her Dad on upper Wisconsin Ave. Sunday. Whether it was the serene glow of a beautiful 8-year-old, or the huge, lime green smoothie she carried, the room got brighter as the two stopped in during their weekend errands.

"This is our regular Starbucks," Sen. Strauss said. Indeed, we've seen him lugging campaign paraphernalia many a weekend since he began serving in the Shadow seat in 1997. He hasn't fielded much serious competition for that seat in some time, but in 2008 Strauss ran for the Ward 3 Council seat now held by Mary Cheh. That was a battle.

More importantly, Samantha allowed that she is in the second grade at Stoddert Elementary School. Stoddert is not far from the site of the annual Palisades 4th of July parade, where Samantha started to come into this world on July 4, 2001. "We rushed her mother to GW Hospital during the parade, and Samantha was born," Strauss said. "That whole parade every year is for her birthday, right Samantha?"

Of course, Dad. So what's on the minds of public school parents these days? In Georgetown, it's turmoil at Hardy, questions about the future of Duke Ellington, and of course the stunning statements made by Chancellor Michelle Rhee to Fast Company magazine that seemed to label hundreds of laid-off teachers as criminals, even child molesters. It may be time for a course called "PR 101" for the high-flying schools chief...


Click here to share your thoughts.


Investigation: Dish Probes Luxury Hotel

January 13, 2010

I arrived to slightly shivering palm trees at the Ritz-Carlton, Naples. Some have called this the best hotel in America. Travel + Leisure calls it the No.1 hotel in Florida in this month's issue. My lawyer told me this. I could hear the meter running skyward as he gave me the history of high ratings of this hotel. A lobbyist I know stopped a conference call to tell a story about the great service he experienced here. My brother says he's always wanted to visit. Is it a guy thing? Lots of golf courses and ocean-front towers shooting up out of the swamp. What makes this a No. 1 hotel? Another friend raved about the linens. High thread count alright, but they're slippery. The Georgetown Dish investigates...


Click here to share your thoughts.